HR News Articles

Did Westpac just mansplain gender diversity to its competitors?

Alison Pullen, Macquarie University and Carl Rhodes, University of Technology Sydney

Australian banking giant Westpac proudly announced a milestone in its gender equality strategy this week, with half of its 6,000 management positions now filled by women. This marks the realisation of a target set in 2014 by then CEO Gail Kelly.


Current CEO Brian Hartzer was effusive, claiming this was a historic moment not just for Westpac, but for Australia. This is a “signpost that our nation is making progress […] for unlocking the potential of women”, he proclaimed.


Gender gerrymandering?


Questions have been raised over whether the 50% women leaders is a bona fide achievement or a PR stunt. Although Westpac is publicly touting its gender parity, its reports to the Commonwealth’s Workplace Gender Equality Agency state that female gender representation in management has been steady (between 36.6 and 38.6%) since 2012.


In the most recent report, that number falls below 30% if only executives and above are included. Let’s be clear, while these statistics confirm entrenched inequality, they are actually at best-practice levels, and reflect the bank’s concerted efforts in diversity management.


But still, the bank’s public posturing belies how much more work really needs to be done before gender equality at work becomes ingrained in Australian business values on its own terms.


Westpac’s claim of 50% is calculated using an in-house approach which, according to one report, has significantly overstated the improvements. This would mean that Westpac’s equality target was not achieved by having more women in senior positions, but by re-classifying the positions it identified as “management”.


The business case for equality


According to the Diversity Dividend Report produced by Deloitte for Westpac, pursuing gender equity in leadership is worthwhile because there is an incontrovertible “association between gender diversity in senior leaderships and firm financial performance in Australia”.


Westpac claim that increasing women in leadership roles to parity with men can boost corporate profitability by more than 2 percentage points “on the back of improved teamwork, culture and engagement with stakeholders”.


This type of unashamedly self-interested business case argument has come under significant scrutiny by diversity researchers for decades. Research shows that the rationale that businesses use to justify diversity programs is almost always based on the business benefits it will deliver.


The danger this brings is that a politics of change and a feminist social justice agenda is stripped out of equality and replaced with corporate friendly strategic plans and key performance indicator (KPI) reports.


This is not without controversy. Researchers have questioned whether equality should be pursued for the commercial returns that it promises, for the benefit of particular women, or because it is a central part of social justice.


Diversity and corporate ‘greatness’


When the business case is used it has even been shown that nominally ethical practices like gender diversity can be less about a genuine concern with justice, and more about a manipulative and narcissistic urge to look good.


In our own work we have surmised that the publicity surrounding corporate ethical initiatives often reduces them to being little more than the pursuit of an aura of corporate greatness – itself belonging to a long standing masculine tradition of competitive self-aggrandisement.


This may well be the case at Westpac, given that reaching the 50-50 target coincided with an extensive marketing campaign including sponsored news stories and funding a free exhibition at the Sydney Opera House entitled “200 Women: The Listening Ground”.


While this might achieve the goal of sharing the stories of real women, it also places Westpac at the centre of gender equality debates in Australia, enabling it to further leverage diversity for commercial purposes.


Competing for diversity


When Westpac promotes its diversity credentials it does so in competitive terms, saying how much better it is than its business rivals. Here ethical and political demands for equality are reduced to yet another form of market competition.


This kind of rational and self-interested competitive behaviour is no way to make real changes to the masculine cultures and structures that drive corporations – characteristics of the very workplace environments that so many women turn their backs on.


To reach equality on women’s terms rather than its own, Westpac should foster institutional practices that support the diversity of women, rather than competitive diversity.


The ConversationEquality is a political imperative, not a corporate one. While organisations like Westpac have in many ways led the way in putting diversity on the business Australia’s business agenda, we should not forget that equality is a basic right that continues to be denied to women. It is worth fighting for, irrespective of the bottom line and the business case.


Alison Pullen, Professor of Management and Organization Studies, Macquarie University and Carl Rhodes, Professor of Organization Studies, University of Technology Sydney


This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

Jobs Just For You, The HR Professional

Our weekly or daily email bulletins are guaranteed to contain only fresh employment opportunities


More info

Latest Jobs

Learning and Development Consultant - Contract - PT
Victoria

HR Officer - 6 mth contract
Victoria

HR Consultant - Contract
New South Wales

Recruitment coordinator
New South Wales

Learning and Development Coordinator - Part Time - Contract
Queensland

Industrial Relations Specialist - Contract
Victoria

Digital Learning Officer - Contract
New South Wales

HR Manager - Contract
Victoria

HR Adviser
New South Wales

Recruiter - 12 mth Contract
New South Wales

HR Consultant - Employee Relations
Australian Capital Territory

Talent Acquisition Specialist - Contract
New South Wales

Senior HR Officer - Contract - PT Option
Victoria

Organisational Development Specialist
Queensland

Employee Relations Specialist
Queensland

HR Administrator
New South Wales

HR Coordinator - Contract
New South Wales

Advisor, People and Capability
Northern Territory

Learning and Development Coordinator
Queensland

HR Advisor, APAC (One-year contract)
New South Wales

Safety Administrator
Queensland

Talent Acquisition Consultant - Contract
New South Wales

Internal Recruiter - Contract
Victoria

HR Administrator & Payroll
New South Wales

Workforce Transition Lead - Contract
New South Wales

Learning & Development Facilitator - Sydney
New South Wales

HR Officer - Contract
New South Wales

HR Manager
New South Wales

Employee Relations Specialist - Contract
Victoria

Learning & Development Business Partner
Victoria

HR Advisor
New South Wales

L&D Consultant - Contract
Victoria

Training Specialist
New South Wales

Talent Acquisition - long contracts
New South Wales

HSE Officer
New South Wales

HR and OH+S Manager
Victoria

Senior HR Business Partner
New South Wales

Recruitment Advisor - Internal - Contract
Queensland

HR Business Partner
New South Wales

OHS / Risk Coordinator - Contract
Western Australia

HR Consultant - Contract
Victoria

Organisational Design Specialist
New South Wales

Internal Recruitment Specialist
Victoria

HR Administrator
Western Australia

Recruitment Officer - Contract
Victoria

HR Manager - Contract
New South Wales

Recruitment Officer
Victoria

National HR Manager - 4 day wk option
New South Wales

HR Consultant - Contract
Victoria

People & Culture Lead - Contract
New South Wales

HR Manager
New South Wales

HR Business Partner
New South Wales

Human Resource Professional - 12 months Fixed Term
Australian Capital Territory

Human Resource Professional - 12 months Fixed Term
New South Wales

HRIS Analyst - Contract
Victoria

L&D Consultant (3 - 4 days a week)
New South Wales

Recruitment Coordinator - Contract
Victoria

HR Business Partner - NSW/ACT
New South Wales

Human Resources Data Analyst - Contract
Queensland

HR Administrator - Contract
Victoria

Streamlined Sourcing Officer - Contract
Victoria

HR Advisor - Part Time
Victoria

HR Advisor
Victoria

HR Business Partner (ER)
New South Wales

Internal Recruiter - Contract
Victoria

HRBP - long contract
New South Wales

Senior HR Advisor
New South Wales

HR Administrator - Contract
New South Wales

HR Advisor
Queensland

Employee Relations Advisor - Contract
Victoria

HR Generalist
New South Wales

Workplace Relations Specialist - Contract
Victoria

Employee Relations Advisor - Contract
Western Australia

HR Administrator
New South Wales

HR Business Partner - Contract
Victoria

Talent Specialist - Contract
Victoria

HR Business Partner - Contract - Part time
New South Wales

Human Resources Business Partner
New South Wales

HR Advisor
New South Wales

HR Advisor - Contract
New South Wales

Browse All Jobs