HR News Articles

These are the characteristics of people most likely to cut corners at work

Peter O'Connor, Queensland University of Technology and Peter Karl Jonason, Western Sydney University

In a newly published study, we found that employees who “cut corners” tend to be morally compromised, low in conscientiousness, self-focused and impulsive. This in addition to the potential for corner-cutting to increase risks.


Surveying more than 1,000 Australians and Americans, we found approximately one in four employees regularly cut corners. Men are slightly more likely to cut corners than women.


Cutting corners at work


Cutting corners is a workplace behaviour characterised by skipping or avoiding steps important to a task, in order to complete the task sooner. Corner-cutting is generally considered an undesirable behaviour, with research linking it to a range of negative outcomes such as low job performance, safety violations and serious injuries.


Although corner-cutting comes with a set of risks, it also comes with a clear possible benefit – cutting corners can possibly lead to greater productivity. Consistent with this, studies have shown that corner-cutting is more likely in jobs characterised by high demands and few resources. It is also more likely in organisations that prioritise efficiency over risks.


However, even in such organisations, corner-cutting is openly discouraged. Mistakes caused by employees cutting corners are typically met with harsh consequences.


To investigate whether corner-cutters can be identified, we surveyed employees from a range of industries including health care, education, hospitality, retail and construction. We looked at several demographic variables and personality traits to determine who is more or less likely to cut corners at work. We focused on both common personality traits (e.g., extraversion, conscientiousness) as well as “darker” personality traits (e.g., Machiavellianism, narcissism).


We didn’t just stop at a questionnaire. We also exposed employees to a hypothetical scenario where they could choose to cut corners or not. We conducted two variations of the study across Australia and the US.


The personality traits of corner-cutters


Across both studies, we found that both common and darker personality traits were associated with corner-cutting. Most significantly, corner-cutters were likely to be low in conscientiousness, low in honesty and high in psychopathy (i.e., impulsive, callous social attitudes). Corner-cutters also scored high in Machiavellianism (i.e., manipulation, self-interest) and narcissism (i.e., grandiosity, pride).


Age and gender were also factors in corner-cutting, such that employees who cut corners at work tended to be younger and male.


But there are also various contexts that play into the decision to cut corners. While a third of employees cut corners when it would likely save them time, they were less likely to do so if they could be reprimanded (only one in six employees cut corners in this situation), or if there was the potential for a poor-quality outcome (only one in four cut corners then).


These results paint a seemingly negative picture of workplace corner-cutters as individuals who are generally self-interested and low in conscientiousness. However, it is plausible that employees sometimes cut corners with noble intentions. For example, the related concept of “workarounds” refers to the more accepted behaviour of “clever methods for getting done what the system does not let you do easily”.


To explore this possibility, we investigated whether corner-cutters were more proactive than those who tend not to cut corners. Our results strongly suggested that this was generally not the case.


Proactive employees were not more likely to achieve their goals by cutting corners at work, even when their goal was to save time. In fact, we found that proactive individuals were slightly less likely to cut corners at work than non-proactive individuals.


We also found little relation between corner-cutting and career success. There was no relationship between corner-cutting and income. However, it was associated with higher income for those who scored high in psychopathy.


This indicates that while corner-cutting generally does not relate to career success, it can result in career benefits for impulsive, self-focused individuals. These individuals are likely to cut corners as a strategy to be more productive, despite possible costs to the organisation or co-workers.


Implications for managers


Overall, we found that corner-cutting is not a desirable workplace behaviour. Those most likely to cut corners are likely to be poor performers aiming to meet minimimal standards in contrast to good performers looking to excel. The possible exception is individuals high in psychopathy looking for short-cuts to get ahead.


The ConversationClearly, it makes sense to minimise the number of employees with corner-cutting tendencies. This is particularly true for jobs in which mistakes caused by cutting corners can lead to serious injury (e.g., jobs in mining, construction). At the very least, we suggest employers take into account certain characteristics of applicants (e.g., conscientiousness, psychopathy) when selecting for such positions.


Peter O'Connor, Senior Lecturer, Business and Management, Queensland University of Technology and Peter Karl Jonason, Senior Lecturer in Personality or Individual Differences, Western Sydney University


This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

Jobs Just For You, The HR Professional

Our weekly or daily email bulletins are guaranteed to contain only fresh employment opportunities


More info

Latest Jobs

Quality Assurance Business Partner
Queensland

Recruitment Coordinator - Contract
Victoria

Talent Acquisition Consultant
Victoria

Recruitment Advisor - Internal - Contract
Queensland

HR Partner - Community Services
Victoria

HR Advisor
New South Wales

L&D Advisor - HR
New South Wales

Human Resource Coordinator (9 month fixed term contract)
New South Wales

HR Shared Services Manager - Contract
Queensland

Head of People & Culture
Victoria

APS 5 Rehabilitation Case Manager - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

HR Manager
New South Wales

Change Manager
Victoria

Senior HR Business Partner - Fixed Term
Victoria

Recruiter
New South Wales

Workforce Business Systems / Data Analyst - Fixed Term to Dec 2018
New South Wales

Return to Work Coordinator - Contract
Victoria

HR Advisor
Queensland

HR Policy & Procedure Officer - Contract
Queensland

Recruitment Coordinator - Internal
Queensland

HR Manager
New South Wales

Internal Recruiter
New South Wales

Learning and Development Manager
New South Wales

HR Business Partner - Contract
New South Wales

Talent Acquisition
New South Wales

HR Manager - 12 month fixed term contract
New South Wales

HR Manager
New South Wales

Director, Organisational Development
Victoria

Recruitment Specialist - Independent Panel Members
New South Wales

Safety Advisor and RTW Coordinator
Victoria

HR Coordinator
Victoria

Workplace Relations Lead
Victoria

Human Resources Business Partner - Contract
Victoria

HR Administrator
New South Wales

HR Project Coordinator - Contract
Victoria

Senior Recruitment Advisor - Contract
Victoria

L&D Consultant | Professional Services Firm | 6 month fixed term contract
New South Wales

General Manager Human Resources
Victoria

Human Resources Administrator - Contract
Queensland

Learning & Organisational Development Consultant - Contract
Victoria

Safer Community Program Coordinator (Re-Advertised)
Victoria

HR Advisor
New South Wales

HR Specialist - Contract
Victoria

Human Resources Business Partner - 12 mth Contract
New South Wales

HR Manager
Western Australia

HR Advisor
New South Wales

Talent Specialist - long contract
New South Wales

HR Global Mobility Coordinator - Contract
New South Wales

Content Producer - Contract
New South Wales

Reward Analyst
New South Wales

HR Coordinator - Contract
Victoria

HR Manager - Contract
New South Wales

Organisational Development Program Manager
New South Wales

Senior HR Business Partner - Fixed Term
Victoria

APS4 Workforce Reporting
Australian Capital Territory

APS4/5 Recruitment Officer
Australian Capital Territory

HRBP | Business Leadership Partner
New South Wales

Talent Acquisition Specialist - Contract
Victoria

APS eLearning Lectora Specialist - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

L&D Specialist - Contract
New South Wales

HR Advisor
Queensland

Talent Acquisition / HR Coordinator - Contract
New South Wales

Human Resources Advisor - Fixed Term
Victoria

HR Analyst
New South Wales

HR Manager
New South Wales

Learning and Development Specialist
Victoria

Recruitment Coordinator - $30ph + super
New South Wales

HR Advisor
Victoria

Recruitment Coordinator - Contract
New South Wales

Talent Acquisition Partner
New South Wales

IR Officer - Graduate role - Contract
New South Wales

HR Manager - Contract
New South Wales

AO8 Strategic Initiatives Manager
Queensland

Safety Learning Associate - Contract
New South Wales

Learning & Development Manager
New South Wales

People & Culture Officer
Victoria

HR Manager (AU & NZ)
New South Wales

HR Manager
Queensland

HR Coordinator
Queensland

APS4 Recruitment Officer - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

Browse All Jobs