HR News Articles

2024 could be the year the Fair Work umpire properly values women’s work – here’s how

Lisa Heap, RMIT University

This International Women’s Day, it is time to call on Australia’s workplace umpire, the Fair Work Commission, to finally close the gender pay gap.


Half a century after the commission’s predecessor granted women “equal pay for equal work” in a landmark case in 1969, the gap remains between 12% and 21%.


Amendments to the Fair Work Act by the incoming Labor government in 2022 gave it new tools to close the gap by addressing the undervaluation of work in traditionally female-dominated occupations.


If it uses these tools to their full potential, 2024 will be a landmark year in the genuine achievement of equal pay for equal work.


What we’ve been doing hasn’t much worked


Traditionally in Australia, addressing gender-based undervaluation has relied on two approaches.


The first has been to argue the business case for gender equality – convincing employers they’ll be rewarded for “doing the right thing”.


The second has been to bring equal pay cases to tribunals.


Unfortunately, neither approach has been successful. In particular, pushing for equal remuneration through tribunals has been time-consuming and expensive.


These tribunals, historically working on models of male full-time wage earners, have struggled to understand the undervaluation of work performed predominantly by women.


The commission’s new tools


The commission’s act has been rewritten to require it to



promote job security and gender equality.



It also has the power to make equal remuneration orders either on its own initiative or on application in order to bring about equal pay for work of equal or comparable value.


A further new development is the establishment of expert panels to assist in gender-related cases. Advice from gender experts should assist in overcoming historical gender biases in commission decisions.


Perhaps the most promising tool is the change to the commission’s modern awards objective, which requires it to eliminate gender-based undervaluation of work and provide workplace conditions that facilitate women’s full economic participation each time it reviews an award.


Among other things, this requirement is likely to result in provisions that ensure part-time work is treated equally to full-time work and ensure a better balance between work and caring responsibilities.


Amending awards is likely to be particularly important for women given that almost three in five of the workers on awards are women. Men are mainly on negotiated agreements.


If the commission wanted to, it could hold a wide-ranging inquiry into the many factors that have contributed to gender-based undervaluation of women’s work.


It could also review entire industries and occupations that are female-dominated, upgrading multiple awards at the same time. This would avoid lengthy and costly reviews of individual awards.


What’s likely in 2024


The Fair Work Commission’s resolve to make lasting change will be tested by several matters currently before it.


The commission is due to issue its final decision in the case lodged by the Australian Nursing and Midwifery Federation, the Health Services Union, and the United Workers Union on the value of the work done by workers in aged care.


An initial interim decision delivered in 2022 awarded some – but not all – of these workers a 15% increase, finding that work in feminised industries had been historically undervalued and the reason for that undervaluation is likely to be gender-based".


Workplace Relations Minister Tony Burke backed the decision, saying it was merely the “first step”.


Another application, for nurses and midwives outside of aged care, was lodged by the Australian Nursing and Midwifery Federation in February this year.


The commission has already started the process of grappling with gender-based undervaluation in modern awards, commissioning research that documents the segregation of women and men into different occupations and industries.


Further research documenting the history of a select group of female-dominated modern awards and identifying the extent to which common elements indicate gender-based undervaluation, is due to be released in April.


It will feed into the annual wage review due by the middle of the year.


How to be bold


Gender-based undervaluation of women’s work won’t be eradicated by incremental adjustments.


Here are three bold steps the commission could take:




  • grant a minimum interim 12% increase (one estimate of Australia’s national gender pay gap) across the board for female-dominated awards in this year’s annual wage review




  • develop new systems for classifying work and ascribing work value, breaking with the previous standards built around skills and qualifications in male dominated occupations




  • better consider the uneven bargaining power in industries such as nursing where governments fund care work and try to restrain costs.




The changes to the Fair Work Act that allow multi-employer bargaining are a start, but unlikely alone to correct the undervaluation of women’s work.


In female-dominated industries where collective bargaining is non-existent or ineffective, the commission should step in and further increase wages.


The Fair Work Commission has been given the tools. This should be the year it applies them.The Conversation


Lisa Heap, Doctoral Researcher RMIT University; Senior Researcher Centre for Future Work at the Australia Institute, RMIT University


This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Jobs Just For You, The HR Professional

Our weekly or daily email bulletins are guaranteed to contain only fresh employment opportunities


More info

Latest Jobs

HR Coordinator - 12 mth Contract
Victoria

Senior Learning and Development Officer
Victoria

HR Manager - Contract
Queensland

HR Advisor - Recruitment - Contract
Queensland

Employee Relations Consultant
Victoria

HR Advisor - Contract
Queensland

HR & Recruitment Coordinator - Contract
New South Wales

Head of People Services - Contract
Victoria

HR Advisor - Contract
Queensland

WHS Consultant - Contract
Western Australia

Principal Advisor (Workplace Mental Health) - Contract
Queensland

P&C Business Partner - Contract
Victoria

HR Manager - Contract
Queensland

HR / Payroll Systems Specialist - Contract
New South Wales

Human Resources Co-ordinator
South Australia

HR Business Partner
New South Wales

HR Advisor - Business Improvement - Contract
Queensland

Human Resources Advisor - Case Management - Contract
Queensland

L&OD Consultant - Contract
New South Wales

Interim APAC HRM
Australian Capital Territory

Interim APAC HRM
Tasmania

Interim APAC HRM
South Australia

Interim APAC HRM
Western Australia

Interim APAC HRM
Northern Territory

Interim APAC HRM
Queensland

Interim APAC HRM
Victoria

Head of People & Culture
New South Wales

Interim APAC HRM
New South Wales

People & Culture Manager
New South Wales

HR Business Partner - Contract
Victoria

Human Resources Advisor - Contract
Queensland

Talent Acquisition Advisor - Contract
Western Australia

Human Resources Manager - FT or PT
Australian Capital Territory

HR Manager - Contract
Western Australia

HR Advisor
New South Wales

HR Officer - Contract
Queensland

People and Culture Business Partner
South Australia

Senior TA Business Partner - Contract
Victoria

Senior P&C Advisor - Contract
Victoria

Strategic HR Business Partner - Contract
Victoria

Remuneration & Benefits Advisor - Contract
Victoria

P&C Business Partner
Victoria

P&C Business Partner
Victoria

HR Manager ANZ
New South Wales

HR Advisor
Victoria

HR Business Partner
New South Wales

Health & Safety Coordinator
Queensland

Principal HR Advisor - Contract
Queensland

HR Advisor
Victoria

Internal Recruiter - Tech - Contract
New South Wales

Recruitment Co-ordinator - Contract
South Australia

Employee Relations Consultant - Contract
Victoria

HR Assistant
Queensland

HR Consultant - Contract - Part Time
Western Australia

Diversity & Inclusion Governance Specialist - Contract
Victoria

Diversity & Inclusion Specialist - Contract
Victoria

HR Administrator
New South Wales

EL1 Assistant Director, Policy - WHS/RCM
Australian Capital Territory

HR Coordinator
Victoria

APS5 Recruitment
Australian Capital Territory

Workforce Planner - Contract
Queensland

Recruitment Officer - Contract
Western Australia

HR Coordinator - Contract - Part time
Victoria

Talent Partner - Contract
New South Wales

HR Advisor - Contract
Queensland

Instructional Designer - Contract
Queensland

HRIS Implementation Specialist - Contract
Western Australia

FIFO HR Business Partner - Contract
Western Australia

Recruitment Advisor - Contract
Western Australia

Senior HR Advisor
Western Australia

Talent Acquisition Advisor - Contract
New South Wales

HR Business Partner
Victoria

Industrial Relations Manager
New South Wales

HR Administrator - Contract
Victoria

Senior HR Business Partner - Contract
New South Wales

Learning Designer | Special Measures - Disability Inclusion
Victoria

Recruitment Advisor - Contract
Western Australia

People & Culture Manager
New South Wales

People & Culture Manager
Victoria

Browse All Jobs