HR News Articles

There's serious talk about a "job guarantee", but it's not that straightforward


Shutterstock


Peter Davidson, UNSW

Suddenly, the idea of a “job guarantee” is back in vogue.


Lawyer, academic, land rights activist and founder of the Cape York Institute Noel Pearson has come out of it favour of it, University of Newcastle labour market specialist Bill Mitchell has a document before the prime minister, and the Per Capita think tank is pushing for a youth-only guarantee.


The idea is that the government would make an unconditional job offer at a minimum wage to anyone willing and able to work. There would be no need for the Newstart unemployment benefit (now called JobSeeker).




Read more: Forget JobSeeker. In our post-COVID economy, Australia needs a 'liveable income guarantee' instead




The buffer of jobs on offer would “normally be small and would shrink as private sector activity recovers”.


It is not widely known that it’s been tried before, by the Keating government in 1994. The scheme was limited to the long-term unemployed, making it more manageable than a scheme that offered employment to everyone who was unemployed.


Working Nation


The centrepiece of Working Nation, unveiled by Prime Minister Paul Keating in February 1994, the so-called “Job Compact” guaranteed subsidised employment for six to 12 months to everyone who had been unemployed for more than 18 months.


This article draws on my research into what happened, including interviews with senior government officials from that time.


By late 1993 300,000 people had been reliant on unemployment payments for more than 12 months.


The idea was that paid work experience in regular jobs would improve their chances of securing unsubsidised jobs by renewing their confidence and skills, and instilling confidence in employers about their ability to work.



We started off wanting to guarantee the long-term unemployed a job. We thought that’s what this agenda was all about (official, department of prime minister and cabinet)



The original plan was for most of the job placements (70%) to be offered through a private sector wage subsidy scheme, Jobstart, which had a good record for placing people in ongoing jobs.



Even with payment, employers weren’t keen to take on subsidised applicants.


The other jobs would be provided through the New Work Opportunities program (which offered community organisations a 100% wage subsidy to employ people fulltime for six months) and Jobskills (which offered a combination of part time paid employment and training run by community organisations).


When fewer private employers than expected took on Jobstart wage subsidies (134,000 in 1995) the job guarantee could only be fulfilled by expanding public and community sector jobs (to 123,000 positions).


As has been the case in other overseas public sector job creation schemes, these jobs often turned out to be very different to mainstream jobs, reducing transitions to unsubsidised jobs.


And as the number of subsidised jobs ballooned, their quality declined. And instead of case managers matching jobs and experience to needs, the process became a conveyor belt.



There was some dissatisfaction even within the department of prime minister and cabinet about how it was going. It appeared to be going the [old] way of not treating people as individuals, just putting people into any program that was coming along (official, department of prime minister and cabinet)



And the language of the program became increasingly punitive.



You often start with a great idea and later it gets modified. Focus groups showed the public were really down on the unemployed and sole parents. That got reflected back in the ‘reciprocal obligation’ language, which was not how we originally had it (official, department of prime minister and cabinet)



Only one third of the participants were in unsubsidised jobs three months after the subsidies ended. The official evaluation of the “net impact” of the program (the extent to which it increased the probability of employment) was a 28% improvement from Jobstart, 11% for Jobskills and 4% for New Work Opportunities.


‘High cost, low outcomes’


The Job Compact was expected to reduce the number of people on unemployment benefits for more than 18 months by 50% in its first year, but the actual decline was less than 20%.


The official evaluation pointed to its “high cost and low outcomes”, and concluded it was “not the most appropriate strategy for assisting the long-term unemployed”.


It said subsidised public sector jobs should be created only to help “the most disadvantaged clients who may not meet the job readiness requirements of many private employers”.




Read more: When the Coronavirus Supplement stops, JobSeeker needs to increase by $185 a week




Right now, 700,000 people have been on unemployment benefits for more than a year, making the case for some sort of large-scale investment in paid work experience and training strong.


Subsidised jobs can help reduce long-term unemployment, as shown by the success of the Future Jobs Fund in the Britain and small-scale wage subsidy schemes in Australia.


Britain’s Conservative Government has just announced plans to generate 350,000 subsidised community jobs for unemployed young people.


But Australia’s experience with the Job Compact shows guarantees are no panacea.


Subsidised jobs help, but they’re no panacea


When subsidised jobs schemes are scaled up to offer jobs to everyone who is unemployed, their costs increase and their quality and their impact on future employability diminish.


We will need large-scale programs to create jobs, and we should offer the 700,000 people who are already long-term unemployed all the help they need to secure them.


But that needn’t always mean subsidised jobs. Many who are unemployed will benefit from training, others from their employment service provider partnering with an employer to skill them up.


Higher unemployment is a price we’ve paid to control the virus. It will take a mix of measures to ensure that cost is only temporary.The Conversation


Peter Davidson, Adjunct Senior Lecturer, UNSW


This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Jobs Just For You, The HR Professional

Our weekly or daily email bulletins are guaranteed to contain only fresh employment opportunities


More info

Latest Jobs

Human Resources Manager (stand-alone)
New South Wales

HR Advisor
Queensland

Human Resources Generalist - Contract
New South Wales

HR Manager
Victoria

HR Business Partner - Contract
New South Wales

Senior Industrial Relations Manager
New South Wales

EL 1 - HR Manager (Assistant Director, Program Management) - Multiple Positions available
Australian Capital Territory

HR Business Partner - PT or FT
Victoria

APS5/6 Recruitment Officer - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

APS5/6 WHS Officer - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

EL2 Recruitment Director - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

Health and Wellbeing Business Partner - Icon Water
Australian Capital Territory

Training Officer - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

EL1 HR Assistant Director
Australian Capital Territory

APS5 HR Generalist - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

Recruitment Advisor - Contract
Western Australia

HR Advisor
Western Australia

Workplace Health & Safety Specialist - Contract
Queensland

WHS Officer
Queensland

HR Advisor - Butterfly - Fixed Term
New South Wales

HR Advisor
Western Australia

Jnr HR Advisor
New South Wales

HR Administrator
Western Australia

Mobilisation Advisor - Contract
Queensland

HR Manager
Queensland

Human Resources Administrator - Contract
New South Wales

AO6 HR Business Partner - Contract
Queensland

Senior Workforce Management Officer
Queensland

HR Business Partner - Contract
New South Wales

HR Advisor
Victoria

P&C Analyst | HR Analyst
New South Wales

AO4 HR Officer
Queensland

AO6 Senior HR Business Partner
Queensland

Recruitment Consultant
Victoria

People and Culture Officer
Australian Capital Territory

HR Advisor - Contract
New South Wales

People and Culture Administrator - Part-Time
Victoria

HR Advisor - Contract
New South Wales

Director of Health & Safety
Western Australia

Strategic People and Performance Partner
South Australia

Talent Acquisition Coordinator
Australian Capital Territory

Recruitment Manager
Australian Capital Territory

Claims Management APS3 and APS4 Roles
Victoria

Claims Management APS3 and APS4 Roles
Australian Capital Territory

Recruiter - Contract
Western Australia

People & Culture Coordinator
New South Wales

Talent Acquisition Specialist - Part time (0.6FTE)
Victoria

Recruitment Advisor - Contract
Queensland

HR Advisor
Western Australia

HRBP
Queensland

Human Resources Officer
Western Australia

HR Administrator - Contract
Western Australia

HR Administrator - Contract
New South Wales

Senior Talent Acquisition Specialist - Contract
South Australia

WHS Coordinator - CDC Victoria
Victoria

HR Consultant - Employment Relations - Contract
New South Wales

Talent Acquisition Coordinator
New South Wales

Recruitment Coordinator - Contract
New South Wales

HR Manager
Western Australia

People & Culture Coordinator
Queensland

Human Resources Officer
Queensland

Human Resources Manager
Australian Capital Territory

HR Business Partner - Contract
New South Wales

Recruitment Coordinator - Contract
Western Australia

Human Resources Advisor - Oakhill College
New South Wales

Senior HR Advisor
Victoria

Recruitment Officer - Contract
New South Wales

Recruitment Officer - Contract - FT or PT
Victoria

Systems Change & Implementation
Victoria

APS6/EL1 HR Officer
Australian Capital Territory

APS6 Senior HR Advisor
Australian Capital Territory

HR Manager
Western Australia

HSE Admin
New South Wales

APS6 Training Officer
Australian Capital Territory

Project Coordinator - Contract
New South Wales

Senior HR Advisor
Queensland

Senior HR Advisor - Contract
Victoria

People & Culture Advisor
Victoria

APS6 Diversity & Inclusion - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

APS6 Senior HR Advisor/Onboarding - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

Browse All Jobs