HR News Articles

Workers bear 71% to 100% of the cost of increases in compulsory super


Wes Mountain/The Conversation, CC BY-ND


Robert Breunig,Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National UniversityandKristen Sobeck,Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University

The government’s much-anticipated Retirement Incomes Review has found that increases in employer’s compulsory superannuation contributions are financed by reductions in workers’ wage growth.


This isn’t obvious, and it certainly isn’t what the superannuation industry has been saying.


Legally, those contributions (at present 9.5% of each wage) come from employers, on top of the wage.


Employers are required to pay them under a legal instrument known as the “superannuation guarantee”.


But employers have to get the money from somewhere.


Compulsory super was introduced in 1992 with the intention the money would come out of funds that would otherwise have been used for wage increases. The document said workers would be



forgoing a faster increase in real take-home pay in return for a higher standard of living in retirement



Government ministers encouraged employers to shave wage increases to pay for increases in compulsory super. In 2012 then minister Bill Shorten explained:



a portion of what would have been employees’ increases will go into compulsory savings



Modelling by the Treasury, Reserve Bank, Grattan Institute, and the private sector has long assumed that is what happens.


Then in February groundbreaking research by the Grattan Institute on 80,000 enterprise bargaining agreements over three decades of compulsory super found that was indeed what has been happening.


Grattan found that on average,80%of each increase in compulsory super has been taken from what would otherwise have been a wage increase.

And now, in work commissioned by the Retirement Incomes Review using completely different data (from the Tax Office instead of enterprise agreements) and an entirely different analytical approach, so have we.


Here’s what we did





Imagine three companies (A, B, and C) offering an identical job in the same city with three different annual total compensation packages: $117,000 (A), $112,000 (B), and $109,500 (C).


The three companies offer the same wage ($100,000), they only differ in the amount of super they pay their workers: 17% (A), 12% (B) and the legally-required 9.5% (C). In this example, total compensation equals wages plus superannuation.


In a competitive labour market (which we largely have in Australia), job seekers would flock to company A, which offers the best compensation package.


How might B and C respond to get workers back?


By offering higher wage growth in subsequent years than A. Higher wage growth would ultimately lead to a catch-up in total compensation levels across the three firms, over time.


Examining the administrative tax records since compulsory super has been set at a single standard rate, that is indeed what we found – when a firm paid super at more than the standard rate, those firms that paid less or merely the standard rate lifted wages by more.


Put another way, the firms that paid their workers more than the legislated rate of super lifted their wages by less.

What happens when compulsory super is increased?


Legislated increases to the standard rate of compulsory super increase firms’ labour costs, but only for firms that pay the standard rate (in our example that’s firm C which we will call a super guarantee “SG” firm).


By comparing the difference in wage growth of employees in “SG firms” to “above SG” firms (companies A and B) during periods when the minimum super guarantee was increased, we can determine how companies pay for the increase in labour costs.



The ATO has insights into super and wages.


We already know that wage growth for “SG firms” is higher than “above SG” firms.


The question is: how does that change when the SG increases?


If “SG firms” find the money to fund the higher SG from somewhere other than wages, it won’t change at all.


If they pass on some or all of the cost to their workers in lower wage increases, then their wage growth should slow relative to that of “above SG” firms.


Our examination of Tax Office data finds this is what has happened.


Our results show that when the legislated compulsory super contributions increased from 8% to 9% in 2002 and again from 9% to 9.25% in 2013, companies passed on 71% to 100% of the cost to workers in the form of reduced wage growth.


What about other findings?


Two other studies, one funded by Industry Super, do not find a trade-off between super increases and wage increases (and in some instances present a case for superannuation increases leading to wage increases).


As we are seeing in the current debates about pausing increases in compulsory super, it tends to be politically easy to raise compulsory super when wage growth is robust and convenient to pause increases when wage growth is slow.


The correlations observed in these studies (that wage growth has been high when compulsory super has been increased) may well be picking up on the timing of increases in compulsory super – that they have been introduced at times when wage growth has been strong rather than having caused strong wage growth.

Where does it leave us?



Source: Australian Tax Office


Increases in compulsory super come at a cost to the wages of workers.


They might result in higher retirement incomes later in life (although this is uncertain because the settings of the age pension mean an increased superannuation balance is not directly correlated with an increase in retirement living standards).


But they leave less disposable income available to workers and their families to consume today or to save through alternative means.


They also cost the government money.


An increase in compulsory super contributions might one day reduce age pension expenditure, a question examined by the review.


But in the years before then, the government would forego substantial tax revenue because the extra super would be taxed at a lower rate than wages.


These are important things for the government to consider as it decides whether to proceed with the legislated increase in compulsory super from 9.5% of salary to 12% in five steps of 0.5% between July 2021 and July 2025.The Conversation


Robert Breunig, Professor of Economics and Director, Tax and Transfer Policy Institute, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University and Kristen Sobeck, Senior Research Officer, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University


This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Jobs Just For You, The HR Professional

Our weekly or daily email bulletins are guaranteed to contain only fresh employment opportunities


More info

Latest Jobs

WHS & Wellbeing Advisor - Part Time
New South Wales

Remuneration & Benefits Consultant
Victoria

EL1 HR Business Partner - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

HR Change Lead (6 months+) - Contract
New South Wales

Senior People Advisor | Permanent
Victoria

HR & HSEQ Officer - Contract
Queensland

HR Coordinator - Contract
New South Wales

Recruitment Officer - Contract
Queensland

Recruitment Advisor - Part Time
Victoria

Internal Recruiter
Queensland

Blue Collar Recruiter - Contract
Western Australia

Change Design Manager - Contract
Queensland

HR Operations Manager
New South Wales

HR Operations Manager
New South Wales

Head of Talent Acquisition
New South Wales

Payroll Team Leader
New South Wales

Remuneration & Benefits Specialist
New South Wales

L&D Advisor
New South Wales

Streamline Sourcing Officer - Contract
Victoria

ER/IR Advisor - Contract
Western Australia

HR Operations Manager (12 MONTH FTC) - Contract
New South Wales

Human Resources Business Partner
New South Wales

Recruitment Advisor
Western Australia

Senior HR Advisor
Western Australia

Workplace Health Safety Officer - Contract
Victoria

ER Advisor - Contract
Western Australia

Injury Management Advisor - Contract
New South Wales

Talent Acquisition Specialist
Western Australia

HR Business Partner (Change Management) - Contract
Western Australia

HR Consultant - Contract
South Australia

APS 6 / EL1 Rehabilitation Case Management - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

HR Advisor - Employee Relations - Contract
Victoria

HR Business Partner
New South Wales

HR Generalist - 3 months Contract
Western Australia

Director People and Culture Business Parnering
Victoria

HR System Coordinator
Victoria

Senior Safety Advisor
New South Wales

EL1 People and Wellbeing Manager - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

Workforce Planning Lead - Contract
Victoria

Senior Advisor - Training & Assessing - Contract
Western Australia

Injury Management Advisor - Contract
New South Wales

HR Advisor - Contract FT or PT
Victoria

Workforce Planning Lead - Contract
Victoria

HR Advisor
Western Australia

Employee Relations Advisor - Contract
Western Australia

HR Manager - Contract
Western Australia

Recruitment Advisor - Contract
Western Australia

Training Delivery Manager
New South Wales

HR Manager - Contract
New South Wales

HR Consultant - Contract
Victoria

HR Manager
South Australia

L&D Specialist
Western Australia

Talent Acquisition Advisor - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

Human Resources Manager - Part Time (0.4 FTE)
Victoria

APS6 HR Officer - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

EL1 Assistant Director Workforce Planning & Development - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

HR Manager
Victoria

Head of HR, Global
New South Wales

Recruitment Advisor - Internal
Victoria

Workforce Management / HR Analyst (12m FTC) - Contract
New South Wales

APS5 L&D Officer - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

HR Business Partner
Western Australia

Senior People Partner – Permanent
Victoria

Human Resources Manager
New South Wales

Internal Recruitment Specialists - multiple vacancies - Contract
Queensland

Workforce Planner
Western Australia

Learning Experience Designer - Contract
Victoria

Training Lead
South Australia

HR Manager - Contract
New South Wales

HR Manager
New South Wales

Recruitment Coordinator - Internal
South Australia

Director People & Culture
South Australia

Employee Relations Advisor - Contract
Queensland

Senior HR Advisor - Contract
Queensland

Talent Acquisition Advisor
Queensland

HR Coordinator
New South Wales

HR Administrator
New South Wales

Recruitment Coordinator - Contract
Queensland

HR Manager
New South Wales

HR Business Partner - Contract
New South Wales

Browse All Jobs