HR News Articles

A memo to Google – firing employees with conservative views is anti-diversity

Akshaya Kamalnath, Deakin University

Google’s recent sacking of James Damore for circulating a memo will do the tech giant more harm than good. Not only has the memo been incorrectly dubbed “anti-diversity”, but a majority of Google employees surveyed in a recent poll disagreed with the decision to fire Damore.


A more productive response to the memo would have been to setup an official channel for employees to air these kinds of issues. This way employees feel their views are heard and the company can take into account different points of view while formulating policy.




Read more: What the Google gender ‘manifesto’ really says about Silicon Valley




Google’s chief executive, Sundar Pichai, wrote to all Google employees saying that Damore’s memo had crossed the line by “advancing harmful gender stereotypes in the workplace”. It might have been more advantageous to have a full and frank discussion of Google’s diversity policies and what they are intended to achieve.


Is it too dangerous to talk about diversity?


Although painted as “anti-diversity”, the memo itself raises issues of the alienation of conservative views at Google and the need to be able to discuss diversity more openly. In other words, diversity shouldn’t be a concept that people are scared to discuss openly for fear of being vilified or shamed.


Damore’s memo suggests that those with differing views on diversity are dismissed and vilified. The response to his memo seems to prove his point. This might in fact be the heart of the problem - fear of saying something politically incorrect might in fact be holding people back from understanding the need for diversity measures.


One study found that American corporate directors thought board diversity (in racial, ethnic and gender terms) was an important goal worth pursuing. But they seemed unable to substantiate this opinion with examples of how board diversity might help the company. The authors of the study concluded that diversity seemed to be a “dangerous” subject to talk about.


Shutting down differing views on the matter is antithetical to the idea of diversity. “Inner diversity”, meaning diversity of viewpoints and opinions, is as important as “outer diversity”, in terms of gender and ethnicity etc.


A Canadian report on women on company boards found that boards with more women surpass all male boards in their attention to audit and risk oversight and control. It also highlights that outer diversity (such as having more women on the board) is a proxy for inner diversity - it is a sign of different “gifts, skills, experiences, and perspectives”. If a company focuses singularly on outer diversity while discouraging diverse viewpoints it won’t realise the real benefits of diversity in the first place.


Rationales for diversity


The rationale for measures promoting diversity is twofold. Women and minority groups have to overcome many barriers including selection bias while being recruited. And diversity, particularly in problem-solving groups, is ultimately good for business.


Diversity measures seek to reduce (if not eliminate) biases by expanding or diversifying the pool of candidates being considered for each position. For example, programs where female candidates are given mentors opens up new opportunities.


Damore’s memo argues the biological differences between men and women might be one of the reasons for the low number of women in the tech industry. However, recent neuroscience research shows there is not enough evidence to conclude that there are significant differences in the male and female brain. So while Damore’s view is not unequivocal, this perception could impede the effectiveness of diversity measures.


Other research shows that more men than women study computer science, engineering, physics and mathematics in the US. This could account for some of the gender disparity in tech companies. However, this is not true in all countries.


For instance, women make up nearly half of computer science and computer engineering students in India. It might be interesting to study what factors deter women in the US from studying these subjects.


But in order to address these issues it is necessary to be able to discuss them, and then assess what a diversity policy is intended to fix. To that end, companies must create forums and events to discuss the rationales for diversity policies and also allow employees to voice their views in this regard.


The ConversationA starting point could be to have employees fill out anonymous surveys to gauge perception of diversity policies. Based on this, appropriate discussions can be encouraged. Companies could also consider making the rationale for the diversity policy available along with the policy itself. This process will result in more informed policy choices and perhaps a more inclusive work culture.


Akshaya Kamalnath, Lecturer, Deakin University


This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

Jobs Just For You, The HR Professional

Our weekly or daily email bulletins are guaranteed to contain only fresh employment opportunities


More info

Latest Jobs

People, Safety and Culture Graduates
Australian Capital Territory

Organisational Development Manager
New South Wales

Senior Advisor People & Change
New South Wales

Senior Recruitment Officer - Contract
Northern Territory

Workforce Planner - Contract
New South Wales

Global Head of Talent Acquisition
New South Wales

Executive, People & Culture
Victoria

Head of Reward & Performance
New South Wales

Health, Safety and Enivionment Manager
New South Wales

Global Reward & Benefits Manager - Part time option
New South Wales

HR Director - Part Time
Victoria

Talent Acquisition Manager
New South Wales

WHS Advisor
New South Wales

HR Administrator
New South Wales

HR Business Support Officer
Queensland

Recruitment Adviser
New South Wales

WHS Advisor - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

Recruitment Business Partner - Contract
Victoria

Rehab Case Manager - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

HR Manager
Queensland

HR Director
Victoria

Workers Compensation Consultant
Victoria

TA Partner - Sydney - Contract
New South Wales

Talent Relationship & Diversity Partner
Australian Capital Territory

Talent Relationship & Diversity Partner
New South Wales

Talent Relationship & Diversity Partner
Victoria

Senior Training Specialist - Contract
New South Wales

HR Coordinator
New South Wales

HR/ Remuneration Administrator - Contract
New South Wales

Senior Manager, Remuneration &; Benefits
New South Wales

Senior HR Business Partner
New South Wales

Leadership Devlopment and Talent Manager
New South Wales

Talent Acquisition Specialist - 12 months fixed term contract
New South Wales

Talent Acquisition Coordinator
New South Wales

HR Advisor - Contract
New South Wales

Human Resources Manager - Contract
Victoria

Senior HR Advisor - Contract
New South Wales

HR Administrator - Contract
Queensland

HR Coordinator - Contract
New South Wales

Senior Payroll Officer (Sydney)
New South Wales

Learning and Development Coordinator
Victoria

Director, Leadership Culture & Engagement
New South Wales

Senior People Partner - Contract
New South Wales

HR Coordinator - Contract
Victoria

Health and Safety Coordinator
Victoria

HR Coordinator - Contract
New South Wales

Senior HR Consultant / HRBP - Contract
New South Wales

Associate Director, Workplace Relations - Contract
Victoria

Manager, HR Systems & Workforce Reporting
New South Wales

Recruiter / HR Coordinator - Contract
Victoria

HR Director, ANZ
New South Wales

Human Resource Manager - 12 months, part time
Victoria

Organisational Development Project Manager
New South Wales

ER/IR Specialist
Victoria

HR Manager- Mandarin Speaking
New South Wales

Internal Recruiter - Contract
New South Wales

National Training Consultant - Contract
New South Wales

Learning & Development Consultant - Contract
New South Wales

L&D Consultant - Leadership Development - Contract
New South Wales

HR Administrator
New South Wales

HR Administrator
Australian Capital Territory

HR Coordinator - Contract
New South Wales

Recruitment Coordinator - Contract
New South Wales

Injury Management Specialist - Contract
New South Wales

HR Manager - 8 months
New South Wales

HR Manager
New South Wales

Talent acquisition specialist
New South Wales

HR Business Partner
New South Wales

Human Resources Operations Supervisor
New South Wales

Learning and Development Manager - 12 months
New South Wales

Recruitment Coordinator - Contract
Victoria

Recruitment Coordinator - Contract
Queensland

Talent & L&D Advisor - Contract
New South Wales

People & Culture Specialist - 12 mth Contract
New South Wales

Creative HR assistant
New South Wales

Hotel - National HR Manager, People & Culture
New South Wales

Instructional Designer/ eLearning Developer
Queensland

Head of People Development APAC
New South Wales

HR Business Partner - 15 mth contract
New South Wales

Senior HR Business Partner
New South Wales

Browse All Jobs