HR News Articles

Remote work requires us to reconsider how to evaluate and pay employees


Many workplaces have dramatically changed during the COVID-19 pandemic. Performance assessments and compensation should reflect the new way of working. Vlada Karpovich/Pexels


Erica Pimentel, Concordia University

Remote work is about more than just working from home — it means working differently. Because working from home may become much more prevalent even after the COVID-19 pandemic has passed, it’s time to adapt employee evaluation and compensation schemes to address the new reality.


Performance evaluation systems have a long history, dating back to the United States military’s rating system during the First World War.


Since then, profit-driven employers have implemented employee assessments with the ultimate goal of aligning worker motivation with organizational objectives. Decades of research have tried to map out best practices in this area.


Social environment is key


While these studies have not been conclusive, many of them suggest that for a system to be effective, it needs to consider the social environment where work takes place, and it must be perceived as fair, both in design and application.


A baby sits on a woman's lap and looks at her laptop.
The work environment has drastically changed for many people who now work from home. (Piqsels)


But existing evaluation processes weren’t designed for the virtual workplace. Now that work is being done differently, organizations need to rethink the types of behaviours that are being rewarded.


For instance, many professional service firms evaluate employees against target utilization rates, or the number of billable hours logged in a 40-hour work week. While this aligns employee goals (maximizing billable hours) to the objectives of a law firm, to name just one example, it places the emphasis on how much work an employee is doing over the quality of work they produce. That’s a vestige of face time culture that was popular in physical workplaces.


A recent survey by Deloitte reports that 28 per cent of organizations award performance rewards based on the achievement of team metrics. Yet the 2018 State of Remote Work survey found that loneliness is a major challenge when working remotely.




Read more: Workers in the gig economy feel lonely and powerless




This means that employees are being evaluated based on team performance even when they feel disconnected from that very team. This raises questions about whether evaluating employees based on team metrics is motivating in the current work-from-home landscape.


What does good work look like now?


Organizations should instead reconsider the appropriateness of their performance appraisal procedures in light of the shift to remote work. This requires a fundamental rethinking of what organizations expect from employees and what companies would look for in a model employee in a remote work context.


It’s likely that the “first to arrive and last to leave” mentality is no longer relevant, but should be replaced by a regard for the quality of an employee’s contribution to the organization more broadly.


This means that work should be measured in terms of the quality of the work, not just the quality of the process (like, for instance, the number of hours worked). Because remote work is largely unobservable to supervisors, employers need to think about how they can objectively measure the quality of work in a way that is consistent for employees of similar rank. This means thinking broadly about what good work looks like.


A man and woman on a Zoom call.
Work should be measured now in terms of quality, not how many hours are put in. (Unsplash)


Focusing on output alone can have the unintended consequence of pushing employees to cut corners or be uncivil in how work gets done. Employers should think instead about the values and soft skills they want to emphasize in a remote work environment. Qualities like flexibility and the ability to work under minimal supervision might become critical.


Much has been written about the importance of timely feedback. In the context of a global pandemic, firms may want to provide additional support to employees by providing more frequent communication. This allows managers to both keep an eye on struggling employees and provide ongoing feedback on how employees are adapting to their new work environment.


Compensation also needs to be revisited


The purpose of performance evaluation is ultimately to determine how to reward employees for their work. This means that pay structures need to adapt to the reality of working from home. However, organizations also need to be honest with employees about the financial impact of COVID-19 on their bottom lines in terms of salaries and bonuses.


For organizations that have struggled to keep the lights on due to the pandemic, this might mean thinking of non-financial ways to reward employees, like unpaid time off or flexible work schedules. Employers can also consider how to bundle different types of compensation to help employees cope with their unique situations.




Read more: Remote work: Employers are taking over our living spaces and passing on costs




Nonetheless, not every organization has suffered during the pandemic. For instance, some of the world’s largest accounting firms have reported record profits this year while implementing layoffs and work-reduction schemes across.


Companies cannot claim to have empty coffers when headlines point to the contrary. This will only breed resentment and erode employee morale.


Bringing the office home


For most employees, working remotely has required at least some investment in a home office.


While there has been some discussion about allowing employees to deduct the costs of maintaining a home office on their tax returns, a more equitable solution would be to provide employees with a stipend to cover their expenses.


Altogether, remote work is shifting how we communicate and behave at work. It’s time we rethink compensation and evaluation structures that were designed for an entirely different type of workplace.The Conversation


Erica Pimentel, PhD Candidate in Accounting, Concordia Public Scholar, Concordia University


This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Jobs Just For You, The HR Professional

Our weekly or daily email bulletins are guaranteed to contain only fresh employment opportunities


More info

Latest Jobs

Human Resources Manager (stand-alone)
New South Wales

HR Advisor
Queensland

Human Resources Generalist - Contract
New South Wales

HR Manager
Victoria

HR Business Partner - Contract
New South Wales

Senior Industrial Relations Manager
New South Wales

EL 1 - HR Manager (Assistant Director, Program Management) - Multiple Positions available
Australian Capital Territory

HR Business Partner - PT or FT
Victoria

APS5/6 Recruitment Officer - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

APS5/6 WHS Officer - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

EL2 Recruitment Director - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

Health and Wellbeing Business Partner - Icon Water
Australian Capital Territory

Training Officer - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

EL1 HR Assistant Director
Australian Capital Territory

APS5 HR Generalist - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

Recruitment Advisor - Contract
Western Australia

HR Advisor
Western Australia

Workplace Health & Safety Specialist - Contract
Queensland

WHS Officer
Queensland

HR Advisor - Butterfly - Fixed Term
New South Wales

HR Advisor
Western Australia

Jnr HR Advisor
New South Wales

HR Administrator
Western Australia

Mobilisation Advisor - Contract
Queensland

HR Manager
Queensland

Human Resources Administrator - Contract
New South Wales

AO6 HR Business Partner - Contract
Queensland

Senior Workforce Management Officer
Queensland

HR Business Partner - Contract
New South Wales

HR Advisor
Victoria

P&C Analyst | HR Analyst
New South Wales

AO4 HR Officer
Queensland

AO6 Senior HR Business Partner
Queensland

Recruitment Consultant
Victoria

People and Culture Officer
Australian Capital Territory

HR Advisor - Contract
New South Wales

People and Culture Administrator - Part-Time
Victoria

HR Advisor - Contract
New South Wales

Director of Health & Safety
Western Australia

Strategic People and Performance Partner
South Australia

Talent Acquisition Coordinator
Australian Capital Territory

Recruitment Manager
Australian Capital Territory

Claims Management APS3 and APS4 Roles
Victoria

Claims Management APS3 and APS4 Roles
Australian Capital Territory

Recruiter - Contract
Western Australia

People & Culture Coordinator
New South Wales

Talent Acquisition Specialist - Part time (0.6FTE)
Victoria

Recruitment Advisor - Contract
Queensland

HR Advisor
Western Australia

HRBP
Queensland

Human Resources Officer
Western Australia

HR Administrator - Contract
Western Australia

HR Administrator - Contract
New South Wales

Senior Talent Acquisition Specialist - Contract
South Australia

WHS Coordinator - CDC Victoria
Victoria

HR Consultant - Employment Relations - Contract
New South Wales

Talent Acquisition Coordinator
New South Wales

Recruitment Coordinator - Contract
New South Wales

HR Manager
Western Australia

People & Culture Coordinator
Queensland

Human Resources Officer
Queensland

Human Resources Manager
Australian Capital Territory

HR Business Partner - Contract
New South Wales

Recruitment Coordinator - Contract
Western Australia

Human Resources Advisor - Oakhill College
New South Wales

Senior HR Advisor
Victoria

Recruitment Officer - Contract
New South Wales

Recruitment Officer - Contract - FT or PT
Victoria

Systems Change & Implementation
Victoria

APS6/EL1 HR Officer
Australian Capital Territory

APS6 Senior HR Advisor
Australian Capital Territory

HR Manager
Western Australia

HSE Admin
New South Wales

APS6 Training Officer
Australian Capital Territory

Project Coordinator - Contract
New South Wales

Senior HR Advisor
Queensland

Senior HR Advisor - Contract
Victoria

People & Culture Advisor
Victoria

APS6 Diversity & Inclusion - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

APS6 Senior HR Advisor/Onboarding - Contract
Australian Capital Territory

Browse All Jobs