Australia’s new pay equality law risks failing women – unless we make this simple fix
Mark Humphery-Jenner, UNSW Sydney
The Albanese government’s efforts to address the gender pay gap are laudable. Despite all the attention given to the issue over the past decade or so, sectoral pay discrimination is very real and workplace biases persist.
But the federal government’s new tool to address the problem, the Workplace Gender Equality Amendment Bill, may not achieve much.
The amendment to the Workplace Gender Equality Act (enacted by the Gillard Labor government in 2012) requires all companies with more than 100 employees to report their “gender pay gap”.
Much like the Modern Slavery Act, the idea is that public reporting will concentrate employers’ attention on the problem, leading to greater gender equality.
But will it?
The problem is the type of data companies must report to the Workplace Gender Equality Agency, which has been publishing pay-gap statistics since being established by the Workplace Gender Equality Act in 2012.
As with the other statistics the agency has published over the past decade, the new amendment requires only publishing simple aggregates:
The Agency must publish aggregate information, for each relevant employer for each reporting period, for the purpose of showing the employer’s performance and progress in achieving gender equality in relation to remuneration for the employer’s workforce"
This may seem like a positive step. But aggregate numbers – which in practice translates into reporting summary statistics – do not help us to either identify or understand the pay gap. Those aggregates also don’t help us come up with the right fixes.
To do that requires better data that enables more precise analysis for the factors affecting pay disparities.
The problem with averages
Averages are ubiquitous in statistics. They can serve a important service, such as identifying trends. I’ll even be using averages to illustrate a few points.
But their limitations should be understood. They are particularly problematic when it comes to areas of endemic inequality, such as income.
Consider a company with 101 employees, one being the founder and chief executive. The other 100 employees, split 50/50 between men and women, are all paid the same salary.
But suppose the chief executive pays himself ten times as much as the other employees. This isn’t ridiculous; the average CEO of a listed company in Australia is paid 132 times the average income. This creates a 17.6% gender pay gap.
Now consider a similar company, run by a “tech bro” who doesn’t draw a salary but does pay every woman 2% less than every man. The aggregate numbers will show no gender pay gap.
In the first case, where there’s no explicit gender discrimination, aggregate numbers can be misread as indicating there is. In the second case, actual gender discrimination is obscured.
The WGEA’s pay gap results
![Workplace Gender Equality Agency's pay gap results, 2013-14 to 2021-22](https://images.theconversation.com/files/509108/original/file-20230209-28-a6yq1r.png?ixlib=rb-1.1.0&q=45&auto=format&w=754&fit=clip)
Poor data leads to poor analysis
The widespread use of averages often skew our sense of things. If you compare your own income to the Australian average (A$90,324 a year in 2021), the probability is you’ll feel left behind. But if you compare yourself to the median income – the income at which half the population earns more, and half less – you’ll feel much better: it’s only $62,868 a year.
Bad data leads to bad analysis, and bad policy responses.
Here’s another scenario. Consider our first company again. The CEO is concerned about the publicity from reporting a 17% gender pay gap to the agency. So he employs his wife as deputy CEO, paying her five times the rest of the staff, and cuts his own salary by half. He no longer has a gender pay gap to report.
This is progress of a kind, but not the progress needed to address the complex causes of gender pay inequality for ordinary people.
How to fix this problem
So how then to improve the reporting of gender pay statistics generally?
Reporting median statistics would help mitigate the skewing problem with averages. Unless the government demands this, the agency will more than likely keeping taking the same approach as over the past decade – relying on averages.
There’s also a case for companies to report other relevant factors that could influence pay, such as qualifications, skill, tenure, seniority and productivity.
This would enable the Workplace Gender Equality Agency to provide more sophisticated analysis, breaking down the factors contributing to the figures that get the headlines.
The agency defines equal pay as “men and women performing the same work are paid the same amount”. To achieve this, it is essential to ensure apples are being compared with apples. This is only possible if we control for the factors that can influence pay, and don’t lose the necessary nuance.
Blunt data does not properly inform us about the pay gap, why it arises, nor how to solve it. This risks policy responses that focus on the wrong issues and which achieve little.
Decision-makers, both in public and private sectors, risk making bad decisions on poor-quality data. The wrong fixes could even make things worse. We will not eradicate the gender pay gap using bad statistics.
Mark Humphery-Jenner, Associate Professor of Finance, UNSW Sydney
This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.
Jobs Just For You, The HR Professional
Our weekly or daily email bulletins are guaranteed to contain only fresh employment opportunities
Latest Jobs
IR/ER Business Partner
South Australia
A04 Project Officer - HR
Queensland
HR Business Partner - Contract
Victoria
IR/HR Advisor - Contract
Queensland
HR & WHS Business Partner - Contract
New South Wales
NSW-based Scribes - Contract
New South Wales
SA Based Scribes - Contract
South Australia
VIC-based Scribes - Contract
Victoria
HR Projects Partner
Western Australia
FIFO HR Business Partner - Contract
Western Australia
ACT-Based Scribes - Contract
Australian Capital Territory
Talent Acquisition Advisor - Contract
Tasmania
Recruitment Coordinator
Queensland
FIFO HR Business Partner - Contract
Western Australia
Senior Human Resources Business Partner - Contract
Tasmania
HR Generalist
New South Wales
HR Advisor - Contract
Western Australia
Organisational Development Specialist - Contract
South Australia
Human Resources Business Partner - Contract
South Australia
HR Business Partner - Contract
New South Wales
HR & Payroll Consultant
Victoria
HR & Payroll Manager
New South Wales
HR Business Partner - Contract
New South Wales
L&D Consultant - Contract
Victoria
L&D Coordinator - Contract
Victoria
Senior Workplace Relations Consultant - Contract
Tasmania
Employment Relations Advisor
Queensland
People & Culture Manager
Queensland
Occupational Health and Safety Programs Manager
Victoria
Health Safety and Wellbeing Advisor - part time - hybrid
Queensland
People and Culture Co-ordinator - Contract
South Australia
EL2 Director, Workplace Relations
Australian Capital Territory
Learning & Capability Lead - Contract
Victoria
Workforce & Recruitment Lead - Contract
Western Australia
Manager of People & Culture
Tasmania
EL1 Assistant Director Performance and Culture
Australian Capital Territory
Senior Human Resources Advisor - full or part time
New South Wales
HR Superintendent
Western Australia
HR Project Officer - Contract
Victoria
HR Business Partner
Victoria
P&C Business Partner - Contract
Victoria
HR Change Lead - Contract
Queensland
Talent Acquisition Team Lead - Contract
New South Wales
Recruitment Project Officer - Contract
Queensland
HR Manager
Victoria
HR Change Manager - Contract
Queensland
HR Business Partner - Contract
Western Australia
Talent Business Partner
New South Wales
HR Advisor
Victoria
Change Delivery Officer - Contract
Queensland
Wellbeing & Safety Advisor - Contract
Victoria
Senior OD Advisor - Contract
Queensland
HR Advisor - Contract
Queensland
Organisational Development Consultant - Contract
Western Australia
People and Culture Manager
Queensland
People & Culture Team Administrator - Contract
New South Wales
EL1 Snr HR Advisor - Contract
New South Wales
Recruitment Resourcer
Queensland
A06 Senior ER Advisor - Contract
Queensland
HR Business Partner
New South Wales
EL1 Assistant Director, Performance & Culture
Australian Capital Territory
HR Manager - Creative
New South Wales
People and Culture Business Partner
Northern Territory
HRIS Aurion Specialist - Contract
Queensland
Senior HR Advisor - Contract
Queensland
Blue Collar Recruiter
Western Australia
Instructional Designer - Contract
Queensland
HR Manager - Contract
New South Wales
HR Business Partner
New South Wales
Workforce Lead- Contingent Labour - Contract
New South Wales
HR Advisor - Contract - Part time
Victoria
Health, Safety and Wellbeing Specialist (0.8 FTE)
Victoria
P&C Business Partner - Contract
Victoria