HR News Articles

Workplaces are turning to devices to monitor social distancing, but does the tech respect privacy?

Ari Trachtenberg, Boston University

As we emerge from the coronavirus lockdown, those of us who still have a workplace may not recognize it. Businesses, eager to limit liability for employees and customers, are considering a variety of emerging technologies for limiting pandemic spread.


These technologies can be loosely divided into two types: one based on cellphone technologies and the other using wearable devices like electronic bracelets and watches. Both approaches focus on maintaining social distancing, nominally six feet between any two workers based on the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention guidelines and supported by some modeling.


Most workers will have little choice whether to participate in their employer’s risk mitigation. As a networking and security researcher, I believe that it is essential that both employees and employers understand the technologies in use, their effectiveness at reducing risk of infection and the risks they may pose to the privacy and well-being of all involved.


The technologies


Social distancing technologies are designed to warn workers when they get too close to each other, typically relying on communications that can travel only short distances. In this way, if your device can “hear” someone else’s device, you’re considered too close to the other person and potentially infected.


Perhaps the most promising communication technology for social distancing is ultra-wideband, which enables precise distance measurements between devices. A more common medium is Bluetooth Low Energy, which is used for headphones and portable speakers, though it may produce less consistently accurate distance information depending on the environment.


Finally, sound itself can be used to determine distance to other people, much like bats use echoes to identify obstacles in their flight paths, with the advantage that it respects wall and door boundaries just like the coronavirus.


Modern cellphones typically can communicate through both Bluetooth Low Energy technologies and sound. Late model iPhones also support ultra-wideband communications.


Contact tracing apps, which are used to alert people when they’ve been exposed to an infected person, generally use these media while loosely adhering to a common design. They include approaches focusing on privacy and security, or precise distance measurements using sound outside of the human hearing range. More recently, Apple and Google jumped into the fray with their own approach that also solves some of the technical challenges that appear to require the cooperation of the two tech giants.


Wearables, which are more limited devices that a person can wear like a bracelet or a ring, can also be used for social distancing. Popular workplace wearables can be programmed to buzz or otherwise alert employees when they get within six feet of each other. These include Halo, Estimote and Covid Radius. Other devices monitor health indicators such as pulse, body temperature or movement.


Will this help?


Workplace social distancing products are designed to monitor the six-foot separation guideline of the CDC. This is a crude measure that is complicated in practice. How long are people in contact? What kind of air patterns surrounded them? Were they wearing masks? Were they singing?


Although some modeling suggests that even crude social distancing can help spread out infection rates over time to help with hospital load, digital contact tracing faces serious challenges of adoption – in order for an infectious contact to be recorded, both parties must be using the technology.


This means, for example, that if 50% of people in a work area – including mail deliverers, IT support and plumbers – adopt the technology, then approximately 25% of the infectious contacts might be identified. If the workplace is already a hot spot for infection, say a meatpacking facility, then the technology only tells workers what they already know: There is widespread infection risk.


What about privacy?


Employers can already legally read employee emails, monitor calls and record video of employees. What additional risk does contact tracing present?


The location data that is used by some contact tracing solutions can be intensely personal. It can identify, for example, with whom workers eat lunch or even what they purchased at the lunch counter. It can identify what fraction of the workday is spent by the water cooler, and even how often and for how long workers go to the bathroom. Without explicit safeguards, employees are forced to choose between keeping their jobs and maintaining their privacy.


Fortunately, some of the solutions do attempt to safeguard privacy in a variety of ways.


Open tech, limited data


It is important that data shared with the employer – or any other third party – should be anonymous and not tied to personal information. Indeed, several of the cellphone-based solutions only share randomly generated data that is useful only for contact tracing apps that tell the cellphone’s owner about potential exposures. Furthermore, some of the wearables do not use a central repository, instead sharing data only among themselves and deleting it after the infection window, typically 14 days.


Some of the technologies prevent employers from accessing employee contact history. In these approaches, only employees who have been near an infected individual are alerted, either through physical feedback like a vibrating buzz or through alerts on their smartphones. Employers are naturally anxious to get a broad picture of worker health, but the greater insight necessarily intrudes on privacy. I believe the ideal scenario is where the worker – and no one else – knows only that he has been exposed to the virus at some recent time, not when, where or by whom.


It may be very difficult for employees to understand what kind of privacy a social distancing system provides without knowing how it operates. Many of the existing products on the market are open-source, meaning that anyone can view and analyze at least some of their code. Some also make all contact information publicly visible, albeit obfuscated, so that there is no mystery about what data is being collected and used.


At the end of the day, social distancing technologies can help protect employees in a post-COVID world. However, absent well-crafted privacy law, both employees and employers must understand broadly how these technologies work, their limitations and their capabilities.


[The Conversation’s science, health and technology editors pick their favorite stories. Weekly on Wednesdays.]The Conversation


Ari Trachtenberg, Professor of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Systems Engineering, and Computer Science, Boston University


This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Jobs Just For You, The HR Professional

Our weekly or daily email bulletins are guaranteed to contain only fresh employment opportunities


More info

Latest Jobs

HR Coordinator - 12 mth Contract
Victoria

Senior Learning and Development Officer
Victoria

HR Manager - Contract
Queensland

HR Advisor - Recruitment - Contract
Queensland

Employee Relations Consultant
Victoria

HR Advisor - Contract
Queensland

HR & Recruitment Coordinator - Contract
New South Wales

Head of People Services - Contract
Victoria

HR Advisor - Contract
Queensland

WHS Consultant - Contract
Western Australia

Principal Advisor (Workplace Mental Health) - Contract
Queensland

P&C Business Partner - Contract
Victoria

HR Manager - Contract
Queensland

HR / Payroll Systems Specialist - Contract
New South Wales

Human Resources Co-ordinator
South Australia

HR Business Partner
New South Wales

HR Advisor - Business Improvement - Contract
Queensland

Human Resources Advisor - Case Management - Contract
Queensland

L&OD Consultant - Contract
New South Wales

Interim APAC HRM
Australian Capital Territory

Interim APAC HRM
Tasmania

Interim APAC HRM
South Australia

Interim APAC HRM
Western Australia

Interim APAC HRM
Northern Territory

Interim APAC HRM
Queensland

Interim APAC HRM
Victoria

Head of People & Culture
New South Wales

Interim APAC HRM
New South Wales

People & Culture Manager
New South Wales

HR Business Partner - Contract
Victoria

Human Resources Advisor - Contract
Queensland

Talent Acquisition Advisor - Contract
Western Australia

Human Resources Manager - FT or PT
Australian Capital Territory

HR Manager - Contract
Western Australia

HR Advisor
New South Wales

HR Officer - Contract
Queensland

People and Culture Business Partner
South Australia

Senior TA Business Partner - Contract
Victoria

Senior P&C Advisor - Contract
Victoria

Strategic HR Business Partner - Contract
Victoria

Remuneration & Benefits Advisor - Contract
Victoria

P&C Business Partner
Victoria

P&C Business Partner
Victoria

HR Manager ANZ
New South Wales

HR Advisor
Victoria

HR Business Partner
New South Wales

Health & Safety Coordinator
Queensland

Principal HR Advisor - Contract
Queensland

HR Advisor
Victoria

Internal Recruiter - Tech - Contract
New South Wales

Recruitment Co-ordinator - Contract
South Australia

Employee Relations Consultant - Contract
Victoria

HR Assistant
Queensland

HR Consultant - Contract - Part Time
Western Australia

Diversity & Inclusion Governance Specialist - Contract
Victoria

Diversity & Inclusion Specialist - Contract
Victoria

HR Administrator
New South Wales

EL1 Assistant Director, Policy - WHS/RCM
Australian Capital Territory

HR Coordinator
Victoria

APS5 Recruitment
Australian Capital Territory

Workforce Planner - Contract
Queensland

Recruitment Officer - Contract
Western Australia

HR Coordinator - Contract - Part time
Victoria

Talent Partner - Contract
New South Wales

HR Advisor - Contract
Queensland

Instructional Designer - Contract
Queensland

HRIS Implementation Specialist - Contract
Western Australia

FIFO HR Business Partner - Contract
Western Australia

Recruitment Advisor - Contract
Western Australia

Senior HR Advisor
Western Australia

Talent Acquisition Advisor - Contract
New South Wales

HR Business Partner
Victoria

Industrial Relations Manager
New South Wales

HR Administrator - Contract
Victoria

Senior HR Business Partner - Contract
New South Wales

Learning Designer | Special Measures - Disability Inclusion
Victoria

Recruitment Advisor - Contract
Western Australia

People & Culture Manager
New South Wales

People & Culture Manager
Victoria

Browse All Jobs